Credit History and Obtaining High Risk Driver Insurance

Title: The Role of Credit History in Obtaining High-Risk Driver Insurance


Obtaining auto insurance can be a daunting task for drivers labeled as “high-risk.” These are individuals who have a history of traffic violations, at-fault accidents, DUI convictions, or other factors that suggest a higher probability of filing insurance claims. Insurance companies assess the level of risk presented by applicants and charge higher premiums to offset potential losses. While several factors contribute to determining insurance rates for high-risk drivers, one factor that has drawn both support and criticism is an individual’s credit history. This article delves into the role of credit history in obtaining high-risk driver insurance and the reasons behind its use.

The Controversial Link Between Credit History and Insurance Risk

Insurance companies use various underwriting tools and statistical data to evaluate risk when issuing policies. One of these tools is the credit-based insurance score, which is derived from the information found in an individual’s credit report. Proponents of this practice argue that there is a correlation between credit history and the likelihood of filing insurance claims. The theory suggests that individuals with poor credit tend to be riskier drivers, leading to a higher probability of accidents and claims. As such, using credit-based insurance scores enables insurers to predict potential insurance losses more accurately.

However, critics of this practice argue that using credit history as a determinant of insurance risk is unfair and may not accurately represent a driver’s actual risk on the road. They point out that driving ability and creditworthiness are two distinct aspects of an individual’s life, and linking them may not be justified. Additionally, some studies suggest that the correlation between credit history and driving risk might be weak or even non-existent.

The Evolution of Credit-Based Insurance Scores

The use of credit-based insurance scores gained momentum in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Insurers found that incorporating credit history into their risk assessment models improved their ability to predict future insurance losses. This led to the widespread adoption of this practice within the insurance industry.

Insurance companies obtain credit-based insurance scores through a specialized scoring model that takes into account various elements from an individual’s credit report. Factors such as payment history, outstanding debt, length of credit history, types of credit used, and recent credit inquiries are typically considered. The resulting score is then used as an additional variable in calculating insurance premiums.

Understanding the Impact of Credit History on Insurance Premiums

For high-risk drivers, the role of credit history can significantly impact the cost of their insurance premiums. A poor credit-based insurance score may result in substantially higher rates compared to drivers with better credit histories.

This scenario is often frustrating for high-risk drivers who may already be facing increased premiums due to their driving records. Consequently, some individuals find themselves in a difficult cycle where higher insurance costs make it challenging to improve their credit score, and the poor credit score further raises their insurance rates.

Improving Your Insurance Situation

While the use of credit history in determining insurance rates may seem like an insurmountable obstacle for high-risk drivers, there are steps that can be taken to mitigate its impact:

1. Monitor and Correct Credit Reports: Regularly check your credit report for inaccuracies or discrepancies that may be negatively affecting your credit-based insurance score. Dispute any errors and work towards improving your overall creditworthiness.

2. Seek Out Specialized Insurers: Some insurance companies specialize in providing coverage to high-risk drivers. These companies may use different underwriting criteria that might be more favorable to individuals with less-than-perfect credit histories.

3. Defensive Driving Courses: Completing a defensive driving course may not directly impact your credit-based insurance score, but it can demonstrate to insurers that you are proactive about improving your driving skills and safety.

4. Comparison Shopping: Obtain quotes from multiple insurance companies to find the most competitive rates available to you. Prices can vary significantly between insurers, so shopping around is essential.


The role of credit history in obtaining high-risk driver insurance remains a contentious issue in the insurance industry. While insurance companies argue that it improves risk assessment, critics claim it leads to unfair pricing and discrimination. For high-risk drivers, the best approach is to be proactive about improving both their driving records and credit scores. By seeking out specialized insurers and actively working to enhance their creditworthiness, high-risk drivers can potentially find more affordable insurance options and break free from the cycle of higher premiums. In the long run, creating a positive driving history and credit profile will likely lead to improved insurance rates and greater financial security.